Barnier rebuffs appeal over citizens' rights in event of no-deal Brexit - THE GUARDIAN
BY Daniel Boffey in Brussels
The EU’s chief negotiator has rejected an appeal by the UK’s Brexit secretary for the full gamut of citizens’ rights in the withdrawal agreement to be protected in the event of a no-deal exit.
In a clear signal from Brussels that it is not willing to countenance a “managed no deal”, Michel Barnier said the suggestion that the citizens elements could be carved out was “far from straight-forward” and that the focus should be on getting the Brexit deal ratified.
While emphasising that British nationals living in the EU would not be “left in the dark” about their rights in the event of the UK leaving without a deal, he insisted to Stephen Barclay that a range of problems existed in ringfencing the rights contained in the agreement, including the continued role of the European court of justice.
Under the terms of the withdrawal agreement, which has been rejected three times by the Commons, the ECJ would give rulings on the interpretation of the rights contained in the agreement. There would be no legal basis for such an arrangement in the event that the withdrawal agreement was not ratified by the Commons.
“Our joint efforts should remain focused on making sure that the withdrawal agreement will be ratified and will enter into force,” Barnier wrote. “We should not be distracted from this essential objective.”
The EU negotiator’s letter to Barclay came in response to a request from the British government for discussions to be opened on ringfencing the citizens’ rights aspects of the withdrawal agreement, a policy agreed by the Commons in an amendment tabled by the Conservative MP Alberto Costa.
The Costa amendment suggested that workers’ rights, from maternity and paternity leave to protections for agency workers, part-time, fixed-term and young workers, should remain for British nationals living on the continent as if the UK were a member state.
The EU’s member states are, on the advice of the European commission, developing their own legislation to protect the rights of British nationals living in their countries in the event of the UK crashing out but there remain areas that are not covered.
Slide 1 of 43: A pro-Brexit campaigner wears the Union flag colours and holds placards as he demonstrates near the Houses of Parliament in central London on April 3, 2019. - Prime Minister Theresa May was to meet on Wednesday with the leader of Britain's main opposition party in a bid to thrash out a Brexit compromise with just days to go until the deadline for leaving the bloc. (Photo by Tolga Akmen / various sources / AFP) (Photo credit should read TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images)
Next SlideFull Screen
1/43 SLIDES © TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
2/43 SLIDES© WIktor Szymanowicz/NurPhoto via Getty Images
3/43 SLIDES© Alberto Pezzali/NurPhoto via Getty Images
4/43 SLIDES© Tim Ireland/AP Photo
5/43 SLIDES© REUTERS/Alkis Konstantinidis
6/43 SLIDES© Dylan Martinez/Reuters
7/43 SLIDES© AP Photo/Peter Morrison
8/43 SLIDES© Dylan Martinez/Reuters
9/43 SLIDES© Artur Widak/NurPhoto via Getty Images
10/43 SLIDES© Andrew RC Marshall/Reuters
11/43 SLIDES© John Keeble/Getty Images
12/43 SLIDES© NIKLAS HALLE'N/AFP/Getty Images
13/43 SLIDES© Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
14/43 SLIDES© Brais G. Rouco / Barcroft Media via Getty Images
15/43 SLIDES© Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
16/43 SLIDES© REUTERS/Henry Nicholls
17/43 SLIDES© Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
18/43 SLIDES© REUTERS/Henry Nicholls
19/43 SLIDES© Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
20/43 SLIDES© Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
21/43 SLIDES© Joe Giddens/PA Images via Getty Images
22/43 SLIDES© Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
23/43 SLIDES© NIKLAS HALLE'N/AFP/Getty Images
24/43 SLIDES© Ian Forsyth/Getty Images
25/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
26/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
27/43 SLIDES© Jack Taylor/Getty Images
28/43 SLIDES© Jack Taylor/Getty Images
29/43 SLIDES© Jack Taylor/Getty Images
30/43 SLIDES© Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
31/43 SLIDES© Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
32/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
33/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
34/43 SLIDES© DANIEL LEAL-OLIVAS/AFP/Getty Images
35/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
36/43 SLIDES© AP Photo/Matt Dunham
37/43 SLIDES© Jack Taylor/Getty Images
38/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Image
39/43 SLIDES© ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP/Getty Images
40/43 SLIDES© WIktor Szymanowicz/NurPhoto via Getty Images
41/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
42/43 SLIDES© TOLGA AKMEN/AFP/Getty Images
43/43 SLIDES© Charles McQuillan/Getty Images
In his letter to Barnier, Barclay said the government had “particular concerns in relation to healthcare arrangements as these are not covered by the current proposals published by the commission”.
He added: “The government’s position remains that the withdrawal agreement provides the best way of providing confidence to citizens.
“Nonetheless, given our shared commitment to protecting the rights of citizens in all scenarios, I would welcome your views on the proposal put forward by our parliament to ringfence citizens’ rights and I propose that we discuss this issue in more detail when we meet.”
Watch: Dominic Raab: Proroguing Parliament 'unlikely' (PA)
- Sadiq Khan: Donald Trump now a poster boy for the far-right London Mayor Sadiq Khan has accused US President Donald Trump of being a “poster boy for racists”. Press Association
- More rain forecast as Lincolnshire flooding clean-up continues Heavy rain is predicted to lash parts of the UK again as flood-hit communities continue to clear up after last week’s downpours. Lincolnshire Police have released footage of flooded fields in Wainfleet to highlight the effort needed to help communities in the region. Press Association
- Tory leadership race: Which six candidates are left? A look at the six contenders who are left in the Tory leadership race as Health Secretary Matt Hancock pulls out of the contest. Press Association
Ad 00:29 - up next: "Dominic Raab: Proroguing Parliament 'unlikely'"
Dominic Raab: Proroguing Parliament 'unlikely'
See more videos
Dominic Raab: Proroguing Parliament 'unlikely'
Sadiq Khan: Donald Trump now a poster boy for the far-right
More rain forecast as Lincolnshire flooding clean-up continues
Tory leadership race: Which six candidates are left?
Tory leadership candidates clash over October deadline for Brexit
Hong Kong government apologises over handling of extradition bill
Harry and Meghan mark Father's Day with new Archie photograph
Brexit: Jeremy Hunt says he would try to negotiate a new deal
Tens of thousand march in Hong KongPress Association0:42
Paris's Notre Dame Cathedral holds first mass since devastating firePress Association1:06
Hunt accuses Corbyn of 'virulent anti-Americanism over Iran threatPress Association0:28
Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe begins new hunger strike in Iran jailPress Association1:11
Tory rivals say no 'coronation' for leadership frontrunner JohnsonPress Association0:45
Hong Kong leader suspends extradition billPress Association1:04
Countdown to Brexit: 138 days until Britain leaves the EUPress Association0:30
RAF drafted in after widespread heavy floodingPress Association0:44
The letter in response from Barnier, however, offered Barclay little succour. There is concern in Brussels that the UK is seeking to renegotiate the withdrawal agreement by stealth.
Barnier wrote that the citizens’ rights part of the withdrawal agreement was part of an “overall and comprehensive approach” to Brexit that could not be picked apart, including the Irish backstop to avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland which Barnier said was to the “benefit of people residing there”.
“It is therefore far from straightforward to identify which provisions would need to be ‘carved out’ as part of the ringfencing exercise proposed by the House of Commons in February, with the risk of unequal treatment of certain categories of citizens.”
In a second letter by the Brexit secretary, Barclay responded: “I agree that our joint efforts should remain focused on making sure that we reach an agreement in order to secure an orderly departure for both the UK and the EU. However, I suggest that together our officials continue to work on how we best protect citizens’ rights in all scenarios.”